Skip to content
Advertisements

#125 Leaning to the Right

January 4, 2012

Screw local ownership and appropriate technology--give me a white guy on a Chinese tractor to get the job done!

Submitted by Greg Vaughan. Find him blogging at Agrarian Ideas for a Developing World.

As an EAW, nothing imbues you with cynicism-tinged street cred like the adoption of mildly conservative ideas.  You will, of course, retain some of your idealism and belief in humanity, but it will now be informed by a hard-nosed pragmatism borne of your years of experience.  Yours will be a strategic idealism that grants you immense field cred.  You will thus become a romantic figure, disappointed by the shortcomings of human beings, but striving on in your world-saving mission in spite of it all.

Such a rightward evolution may arise from a disillusion with local people and/or the international development scene: “Aid money has only bred laziness and corruption here in Sierra Leone.  What this country really needs is foreign-owned textile factories.”

Or you may undergo an extreme, unquestioning internalization of local values:  “Suffocating women in burqas and social censure is a way of protecting them.  It’s much better than the lurid objectification of women we label as freedom in the West.” or “Universal formal education is a silly Western imposition.  The widespread child labor in India is an integral part of the country’s culture.”

A turn to the right can even come from observations with a strand of objective truth and cutting insight:  “Sure, the Duvaliers created a reign of terror, but Haiti was a much more prosperous, functional country under their watch.”

Issues of sovereignty and Third-World solidarity are also good motivators:  “China is doing the right thing by pursuing their interests through alliances with resource-rich dictatorships.  They’re honest about their goals, unlike the hypocritical Western countries who wring their hands about human rights even as they exclude up-and-coming countries from the established oil fields.” Or “The Amazon is Brazil’s to do with as it pleases.  Europe and the US cut down their forests to develop their economies, so Brazil should be free to do the same.”

Whatever the cause of your flirtations with reactionary thinking, you are demonstrating an admirable capacity to go outside the box and challenge the progressive mores of your EAW colleagues.

Care must be taken, however, to nuance your stances so as to separate them from First-World-based talking heads like Paul “Sweatshops for Haiti” Collier or Bill “Hook African Farmers on Imported Fertilizer” Gates.  These ideologues are ignorant of the realities on the ground, unlike you, and consequently paint with excessively broad brush strokes.

Your newfound conservatism should not take on tones of cultural or racial superiority, lest you be confused with a rigid-thinking new arrival, or worse yet, an Evangelical missionary.  It must be clear that your cynicism is an evolution beyond the normal EAW’s natural liberal leanings, not merely an unconsidered initial state.

To help you along your ideological transition, it is useful to have an authentic local friend to provide moral support and credibility to your conservative ideas.  Usually this friend will belong to an important family whose economic and political fortune has been made precisely by advancing the exploitative, oppressive agenda he is now helping you to understand.

Advertisements
9 Comments leave one →
  1. January 4, 2012 5:50 am

    Can I add to this list: being against the International Criminal Court as it’s just an idealised, Western institution which only makes things worse for local people – “sure, Al Bashir is an evil despot but he let NGOs work until the western bureacrats waded in”

  2. Kim permalink
    January 4, 2012 7:05 am

    Love this. It’s just perfect!

  3. January 6, 2012 10:34 am

    How is this right-leaning? E.g. cultural relativism can be seen throughout the spectrum of political right-to-leftness and using third-world solidarity as an argument is originally a left-wing concept.

    (And to be clear: I am saying this as a lefty.)

    • January 6, 2012 4:01 pm

      That’s why it’s so funny–cultural relativism and solidarity arising from progressive values can lead one to accept or even support reactionary values in other cultural contexts.

  4. January 17, 2012 10:06 am

    Best. Example. Ever. http://www.globaldashboard.org/2012/01/17/piracy-the-new-aid/

  5. Sally McManus permalink
    March 31, 2012 5:36 pm

    This is an excellent article…particularly as I found myself discussing (and agreeing) how “the International Criminal Court is just an idealised, Western institution which only makes things worse for local people” with some African colleagues the other day. Not to say this point of view is wrong, or right, but the article is a good wake-up call for me to keep thinking outside the box, both the EAW box and the pure local context box… Thanks.

Trackbacks

  1. Telling Positive Stories – The backlash | UpLook
  2. Positive Stories for Africa? « Generation C Magazine
  3. Mubruk [Congratulations] America! « Jillian Sans Frontières

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: